Florida Insurer Required to Produce Its Attorneys’ Time and Billing Records to Prevailing Bad Faith Claim Insured
Summary: Kelly Paton was injured when her vehicle was struck by an underinsured driver (“UIM”). At the time, Paton was covered by an insurance policy issued by GEICO. GEICO failed to pay the full amount due under the UIM provision and Paton filed suit. Paton obtained a jury verdict in her favor on a breach of contract and a bad faith claim. As the prevailing party, Florida’s bad faith law entitled Paton to attorneys’ fees. Paton then served discovery requests on GEICO seeking to obtain GEICO’s billing and time records and lodestar fee interrogatories. GEICO objected, arguing that the records were privileged and irrelevant. The trial court overruled GEICO’s objection, but the Court of Appeals quashed the trial court’s orders requiring GEICO to produce the time records.