Successes
Powell v. Scenic Nursing. In 2021, Steve presented this case for a two-day arbitration before Judge Barbara Wallace. This arbitration was conducted by Zoom. Plaintiff alleged multiple incidents of sexual assault by a nurse over several months. The arbitrator entered a complete award in favor of the nursing home and its employees.
Smith v. Toyota Motor Corporation. In 2018, Steve represented an automobile manufacturer in a case involving the driver of a 1997 Toyota 4Runner who was ejected during a rollover. The plaintiff sustained catastrophic injuries, including a brain injury. The Hannibal, Missouri Federal Court jury rendered a verdict in favor of the manufacturer.
Johnson v. Riverside Nursing. This case against client Riverside Nursing involved a fall by a visitor, who claimed significant back injuries as a result of the fall. After a trial in August, 2016, a Platte County, Missouri jury rendered a verdict in favor of Riverside Nursing.
Fulbright v. National HealthCare Corporation. This nursing home case was presented for a two-day arbitration in October, 2014. An 85 year-old nursing home resident suffered multiple fractures during a transfer into a transport van. The arbitrator entered a complete award in favor of the nursing home.
Owensby v. Riverside Nursing. This nursing home case was scheduled to be tried in Platte County, Missouri in May, 2012. It was filed in 2009, and alleged negligence and wrongful death of an 87 year old resident receiving hospice care. Plaintiffs alleged their father died from administration of too much morphine. After litigating the case for three years, including numerous depositions, the plaintiffs agreed to a dismissal with prejudice without the payment of any money.
Hall v. Cooperative Workshops, Inc. In November, 2011, Steve tried this two-week long wrongful death case in Pettis County, Missouri. It involved the traumatic crushing death of a 56 year-old husband and father. The decedent, a tractor-trailer driver, was standing between another tractor-trailer and a loading dock. Steve’s client was an employee of Cooperative Workshops, Inc., who allegedly instructed the tractor-trailer driver that he had permission to back up. Upon backing up, the tractor-trailer pinned the decedent to the loading dock, crushing him to death. The economic losses were approximately $1 million, and plaintiffs’ counsel asked the jury for an award of $4.5 million. The jury determined the decedent was 100% responsible for his own death.
This case was listed as the #8 defense verdict in the State of Missouri for 2011 by the Missouri Lawyers Weekly.
Nelson v. Walnut Ridge. This nursing home case was tried in Sangamon County, Illinois in May, 2009. A 70 year-old resident experienced a fall, resulting in a fractured hip. In addition, the resident developed dehydration and an infection, resulting in sepsis and death. The Court entered a Directed Verdict in favor of the consulting company defendant. A jury rendered a verdict against the nursing home defendant, and the amount was half the final settlement offer before trial.
Maday v. Scenic View. This nursing home case was tried in the City of St. Louis in April, 2008. An 80 year-old resident was removed from her ventilator by an unlicensed Respiratory Therapist, and died four days later. The plaintiff alleged that no physician had ordered her removal from the ventilator. The Respiratory Therapist was charged and entered a plea of involuntary manslaughter as a result of the incident. Plaintiff’s counsel sought $4.0 million from the jury. The jury rendered a verdict against the nursing home for $26,000 (the amount of the medical specials).
Schwab v. Rosewood. This nursing home case was tried in Madison County, Illinois in October 2007. An 82 year-old resident fell and fractured her neck, requiring significant cervical surgery. The resident died five months later. The medical specials associated with the injury were $175,000. Plaintiff’s counsel sought $1 million in closing argument. After nearly 20 hours of deliberations over the course of three days, the jury rendered a verdict for plaintiff just over $58,000.
Klevorn v. Easter Seals of Missouri. In 2007, Steve represented Easter Seals of Missouri in a case involving a 15 year-old autistic child who sustained a fracture to his arm. Plaintiff alleged intentional abuse of the child while trying to remove a pen from his hand. The case settled just prior to closing arguments.
Miller v. Levering Regional. In 2005, Steve represented a nursing home with respect to the death of a 91 year-old resident who sustained a fall and died sixteen hours later. The jury rendered a verdict for the plaintiff.
White v. Cutler-Hammer. In 2003, Steve represented the manufacturer of a circuit breaker, where plaintiff alleged that a product defect caused a residential fire. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of the plaintiff.
CGU v. Cutler-Hammer. In 2002, Steve represented the manufacturer of a circuit breaker, where the plaintiff alleged it malfunctioned and caused $1.5 million in property damage. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of the defendant.
Bell v. Toyota Motor Corporation, et al. In 2000, Steve represented an automobile manufacturer in a case involving a sixteen year old paraplegic. After a three week trial, the Joplin, Missouri jury rendered a verdict in favor of the manufacturer. This case was listed as the #2 defense verdict in the State of Missouri for 2000 by the Missouri Lawyers Weekly.
Redfield v. Beverly Health et al. In 1999, he represented a nursing home with respect to the death of a ventilator-dependent quadriplegic residing in the home. The jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff.
Ragle v. Beverly Enterprises, Inc., et al. In 1998, Steve represented a nursing home operator in a wrongful death case as a result of a man who allegedly wandered from the home and died from the sub-zero temperature. The federal court jury rendered a verdict in favor of the plaintiff in the amount of $1.00. Steve was able to convince the jury that the plaintiff, the decedent’s daughter, should receive merely a nominal award since she had not seen her father for nearly 20 years before his death. The jury rejected plaintiff’s prayer in the amount of $6 million. This case was listed as the #1 defense verdict in the State of Missouri for 1998 by the Missouri Lawyers Weekly and an Honorable Mention of the top defense verdicts in the country for 1998 by The National Law Journal.
Wayne v. Burlington Motor. In 1998, Steve represented an individual whose vehicle was struck by a tractor-trailer. As a result, the plaintiff had three cervical discs removed, and was fused from C-4 to C-7. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of his client in the amount of $2.1 million.
Adams v. Whelan Security, et al. In 1996, Steve represented a security company and its employed guard who shot a teenager, rendering him a C-6 quadriplegic. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of the plaintiff.
