Summary: Infinity Assurance Insurance Company insured Ben Purscell’s car when he was involved in a serious auto accident leading to a serious injury and a death. His liability limits were only $25,000/$50,000. Infinity was unable to settle the underlying case which resulted in verdicts exceeding $900,000. Purscell filed a bad faith failure to settle and breach of fiduciary duty case against Infinity. The district court judge entered summary judgment for Infinity which was affirmed on appeal.